Haunted Finger Lakes Locations

The Naples Hotel:

The Naples Hotel, built in the early 1800s, is said to be haunted by the ghost of a former owner named Laura. Guests have reported hearing footsteps, seeing apparitions, and experiencing strange occurrences in their rooms.

The Mansion on Keuka Lake:

This historic mansion on the shores of Keuka Lake is believed to be haunted by a well dressed woman whose origin story is unknown. The Greek revival mansion is an Underground Railroad landmark.

1890 House & Museum

Featured on SyFy’s Ghost Hunters, the 1890 Museum in Cortland annually hosts Spirits in the Castle, where participants join up with Knightime Paranormal to investigate the Victorian-era stone castle known as the Wickwire Mansion. Learn about the death of Chester Wickwire and hunt for ghostly occurrences in this haunted mansion. For something a bit more theatrical, the museum is also host to Séance Revealed, where the participating audience is led in a Victorian séance. Following the séance, the curtains are thrown back as performers reveal the tips and tricks for creating paranormal happenings. For tickets, dates, and times, check here.

The Museums of Historic Palmyra

For some ghostly action, head to Palmyra, which has been featured on The Ghost Finders and visited by a number of ghost detectives, seekers, and more. The five historic museums of Palmyra bring a number of spooky events. Starting in September, for thrill seekers and history buffs who want to get started early on that Halloween vibe, join the World’s Largest Ghost Hunt in honor of National Ghost Hunting Day on Sept. 28. Ghost hunting teams investigate paranormal activity throughout the town, teaming up with investigators from across the world via live streaming.

Later in October, Palmyra is also host to Historic Palmyra’s Famous Cemetery Walk and the Para Expeditions Ghost Hunt at Historic Palmyra, where participants will go on a guided tour of the area and learn about paranormal activity as well as be given opportunities to connect with those from the beyond. For tickets, dates, and times, check here. 

Genesee Country Museum

You’ll step into the past when you visit the Genesee Country Museum any day of the year, but during Spirits of the Past Theatrical Tours the historic village is transformed into a place where ghouls rule. Throughout the evening, you’ll be entertained by spine-chilling historical accounts, folklore, and literature, all of which will be explored and performed by costumed characters by the flicker of candlelight. For tickets, dates, and times, check here.

Seward House

Spend the evening learning about spooky folklore, local crimes, and more by participating in the Haunted History of Seward House tour across the grounds of Seward House and through downtown Auburn, led by guides garbed in costume to really set the tone of this chilling expedition. For tickets, dates, and times, check here.

Belhurst Castle

A more recent addition the New York State’s Haunted History Trail, Belhurst Castle, with its amazing lake views and grand presence, is also believed to be haunted. While there’s no specific tour, you can try to catch a glimpse of Isabella, an opera singer that legend says perished at the castle and has been said to still roam the grounds, by booking a room, a spa service (named Isabella Spa-Salon after the famous specter), a wine tasting, or a reservation for dinner. For more information, check here.

Historic Ithaca

At night, there’s nothing quite as creepy as walking through a cemetery. But in the daylight, it’s not quite as frightening, which makes this daytime cemetery tour a family-friendly event. Participants of the Historic Ithaca Cemetery Tour will learn about the cemetery’s evolution through time and hear tales about storied residents. For tickets, dates, and times, check here.

Sonnenberg Gardens

Although not officially haunted—though the historic mansion certainly sets the scene—Sonnenberg Gardens in Canandaigua comes alive with spooks during its annual Haunted Stroll through the gardens. Snacks can be purchased at this family-friendly event. For more information, check here.